Seasonal · Week of June 21 - 27, 2026
Pumpkin Pie Cookie
★★★★☆ 4.4 / 5
A cookie-crust take on pumpkin pie with spiced custard-like filling.
Last updated
About the Pumpkin Pie Cookie
The Pumpkin Pie Cookie reframes a holiday pie as a single serving. A cookie crust holds a spiced, custard-like pumpkin center, often finished with a touch of cream, so it captures the pie experience without the slice. The spice level is warm and familiar rather than aggressive.
Like the Pumpkin Square, this is a seasonal item that mostly shows up in fall. Serve it cool, and coffee is the natural companion for that holiday-dessert feel.
Serving & pairing tip
Seasonal; serve cool, classic with coffee.
Allergens
- Wheat Contains gluten from wheat flour.
- Egg Contains egg.
- Milk Contains dairy / milk.
Allergen and calorie details are independent estimates and can change weekly. Always confirm in store, especially for serious allergies.
Related cookies
Seasonal
Pumpkin Square Cookie
$4.99Seasonal
A spiced pumpkin bar with cream cheese frosting for the fall rotation.
Rotating
Banana Bread Cookie
$4.99Cake
A soft, spiced banana bread base finished like a bakery loaf in cookie form.
Rotating
Cookie Dough Cookie
$4.99Classic
A baked chocolate chip cookie topped with edible cookie dough and chips.